ARTICLE: "The Liberal Gloat"
by Ross Douthat
I'm posting this opinion piece, because I think that this opinion piece and one of the comments responding to it, were both very thought-provoking.
In his editorial, Douthat posits a common refrain/warning that Republicans make, namely that:
foster stability, encourage solidarity and make mobility possible.
To his credit, this piece isn't a mindless attack on liberals, per se, but still, the arguments he makes seemed a bit skewed.Then I read one of the comments responding to the article and I felt like it did a good job of explaining what I was thinking:
- winiznayne
- albuquerque, nm
The problem with the right is that they see the failure of social institutions as the cause of societal decay instead of the other way around. It's not the failure of the family, community, church that is the core of the problem. The core of the problem, (and the cause of the downfall of these institutions) is the rising inequality enacted by thirty years of Republican policies of deregulation, tax cuts, union busting, etc.
Republican economic policy is completely at odds with conservative social positions. It's an economic policy that openly embraces inequality and a social policy that demands that people help themselves. A policy that embraces privatization of everything, forcing people to make more purchases of every day products, but one that resists wage increases among workers at every point. The list goes on.
These contradictions breed a cynical attitude among society. Low-wage families can't thrive under such pressures, and churches refuse to acknowledge the insensitivity and absurdity of these policies. It is really hard not to see the Republican party, and conservatives in general, as a group of out of touch elitists who can't seem to understand why poor people aren't richer, why immigrants aren't maintaining families, why working-class people aren't intellectual. The core of the problem is the economics. Focus on the inequality, not the ramifications.
Republican economic policy is completely at odds with conservative social positions. It's an economic policy that openly embraces inequality and a social policy that demands that people help themselves. A policy that embraces privatization of everything, forcing people to make more purchases of every day products, but one that resists wage increases among workers at every point. The list goes on.
These contradictions breed a cynical attitude among society. Low-wage families can't thrive under such pressures, and churches refuse to acknowledge the insensitivity and absurdity of these policies. It is really hard not to see the Republican party, and conservatives in general, as a group of out of touch elitists who can't seem to understand why poor people aren't richer, why immigrants aren't maintaining families, why working-class people aren't intellectual. The core of the problem is the economics. Focus on the inequality, not the ramifications.
What do you guys think?
No comments:
Post a Comment